Best Carbon Steel Pans

Reviewed By: KRG Staff
Review Date:
Est. Read Time: 0 min
KitchnGuide.com is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more here.

Best Overall Pan
Overall Score
9.45
We just got our hands on the Made In Cookware Carbon Steel frying pan and we have to say, we’re pretty impressed. This is definitely a step up from cast iron. It’s lighter, responds quicker, and is more maneuverable – perfect for high-heat searing. The sloping walls and wide surface make it easy to get maximum heat contact, so your food cooks evenly every time. Plus, the pre-seasoned with bassao oil, coconut oil, and sunflower oil makes it ready to use right out of the box – no hard seasoning required. We can’t wait to put this pan to use in our kitchen!
Runner Up for Best Overall
Overall Score
8.61
We love our de Buyer Carbon Steel Country Pan! It heats evenly and has a naturally nonstick surface that needs no synthetic coating. The darker the better with this pan, as the beeswax finish protects against oxidation. It’s also oven-safe and induction-ready. We found it to be an essential kitchen tool for whisking sauces, making ice cream, and more. Engineered and manufactured following the most stringent quality requirements, it’s no wonder this pan is a favorite among chefs.
Overall Score
8.5
Merten & Storck Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel skillet – lightweight, quick heating carbon steel skillet outperforms our cast iron skillets. The nonstick patina that forms with use is amazing- the more you cook, the more nonstick it gets! The sturdy stainless steel handle is riveted to create a sturdy hold, and the silicone coating on the skillet protects it during shipping. We’re looking forward to many years of use with this fantastic skillet!
Overall Score
8.23
The Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Fry Pan! It’s a great addition to our kitchen. The pan is made of natural mineral material, so it’s healthy and free of harsh chemicals or coatings. The steel handle is welded to the pan’s body for extra strength and security. It’s also free of rivets, which prevents bacteria from being trapped. This makes it ideal for sanitary use. The angled design of the handle makes it easy to saute, stir, and mix your food. We highly recommend this fry pan!

Read Our Recent Brand Reviews

hexclad cookware review
HexClad Cookware Review

HexClad’s signature technology for the cooking surface of their cookware is a […]

Written By: KRG Staff
Reviewed Date: December 15th, 2022
all clad cookware on kitchen countertop
All-Clad Cookware Review

All-Clad is a high-quality, high-performing cookware brand that comes with a lifetime […]

Written By: KRG Staff
Reviewed Date: November 30th, 2022
Best Stainless Cookware Set
Made in Cookware Review

Founded in 2017, Made In Cookware is a trusted brand known for […]

Written By: KRG Staff
Reviewed Date: August 4th, 2023

Recent Product Reviews

Keep learning about the best kitchen products for your home and read our latest reviews.

Best Stainless Cookware Set
Best Cookware Set | 2024

Are you in the market for a new cookware set? If so, […]

Written By: KRG Staff
Reviewed Date: January 16th, 2024
best dutch oven - Made in Cookware Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven
Best Dutch Oven | Researched, Reviewed & Tested

Overall Best Dutch Oven The Perfect Dutch Oven The best dutch ovens […]

Written By: KRG Staff
Reviewed Date: November 20th, 2023
Best Griddles

Why Everyone Should Own a Griddle Griddles are one of the most […]

Written By: KRG Staff
Reviewed Date: February 28th, 2024