Kitchen Review Guide is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page.
A good nonstick pan releases a fried egg without oil, browns evenly from center to rim and keeps its coating for years, not months. We compare coatings, bases and build to find the pans that hold up to daily cooking.
As Featured In
MADE IN™
BEST FOR: Cooks who want slick, restaurant-grade release with the heat control of fully clad stainless. The 5-ply body resists warping, works on induction and goes into a 500 degree F oven to finish frittatas.
KEY SPECS
| Nonstick Frying Pan | Score | Quality | Durability | Material | Size | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Made In™ — 10 Inch Nonstick Pan | 9.87 | Premium | Stainless Steel | 6", 8", 10" and 12" | Shop Now | |
| Calphalon — 13 Inch Deep Skillet | 8.21 | Good | Nonstick | 13 In. | Shop Now | |
| OXO — Nonstick Pan | 7.46 | Good | Average | Aluminum | 10 In. | Shop Now |
| Nordic Ware — Nordic Ware Pan | 7.29 | Good | Nonstick | 10 In. | Shop Now | |
| Misen — Nonstick Pan | 6.98 | Good | Nonstick | 8 In. | Shop Now |
We evaluate every nonstick pan with four tests. Dry-fried eggs reveal true coating release. A full-surface crepe exposes hot spots and uneven edges. Repeated heat cycles check for warping and flat induction contact. An abrasion pass, followed by a second egg test, shows how long the coating will last.
#2 · RUNNER-UP
Calphalon
SCORE 8.21
#3 · THIRD PLACE
OXO
SCORE 7.46
#4
Nordic Ware
SCORE 7.29
#5
Misen
SCORE 6.98
A fully clad body with an aluminum core spreads heat evenly, resists warping and sits flat on induction. Thin stamped aluminum heats fast but can dome under high heat and develop hot spots.
Every nonstick coating wears out. Multi-layer PTFE coatings usually hold their release longer than ceramic, which avoids PTFE but loses slickness sooner. Check the coating warranty, not just the pan's.
A rating of 450 to 500 degrees F lets you finish frittatas and fish in the oven. Look for a stainless handle, and confirm the rating covers the coating itself, not only the metal body.
Hand wash only. Dishwasher detergent and heat wear down nonstick faster than any utensil. Wash with a soft sponge and mild soap, never steel wool or abrasive powder.
Cook over low to medium heat. The clad base holds heat well, and high flame overheats the coating. Use silicone or wood tools, skip aerosol sprays, and let the pan cool before washing to prevent warping.Stack with a towel between pans. Replace the pan when eggs stick or the coating flakes.
Modern PTFE coatings are made without PFOA and are considered safe for normal cooking. The risk comes from heating an empty pan well above 500 degrees F, when the coating can break down and release fumes. Cook at low to medium heat and never preheat dry on high.
Ceramic avoids PTFE and tolerates higher heat, but its release typically fades faster with daily use. Multi-layer PTFE stays slick longer, especially for eggs and fish. Choose ceramic to avoid PTFE; choose PTFE for longer-lasting release.
Even premium coatings are wear items. Expect about 2 to 5 years of daily use, depending on heat, utensils and washing. A heavy clad body will not warp, so when a quality pan fails, it is the coating that goes, not the pan.
Only if the base is magnetic. Clad pans with a stainless exterior work on induction and stay flat, so contact stays even. Plain aluminum pans need a bonded steel disc. Hold a magnet to the underside before you buy.
Keep learning about the best kitchen products for your home and read our latest reviews.
